The College of New Rochelle Blue Angels, who make their home in the College's new Wellness Center, are an NCAA Division III athletic program and a member of the Association of Division III Independents (D3 Independents) and locally the Hudson Valley Women’s Athletic Conference (HVWAC). The Blue Angels have a rich athletic history, which includes numerous NCAA records and All American selections.

With competitions offered in Basketball, Volleyball, Softball, Tennis, Swimming, and Cross Country, the College offers a varied and competitive program. Cheerleading is offered as a year-round program administered by the Athletic Department. Club Soccer has been a recent addition to the athletic program.